a STOF: service, technological, organizational, and financial.
b mHealth: mobile health.
c B2C: Business-to-Consumer.
d B2B: Business-to-Business.
e SHAAL: Smart Home and Ambient Assisted Living.
The results of Marjomaa's study [ 38 ] showed that the eHealth service market for chronic diseases was a multidisciplinary market with several different segments, and the use of a participatory strategy such as the Osterwalder business model had a significant impact on the success of this market. Leeuwerden has suggested that cost-benefit studies are essential for the success of assisted living technologies in dementia care, and they can be considered along with the components of the Osterwalder model [ 39 ]. Similarly, the results of a study conducted by Kho et al showed that although the Osterwalder model can be considered as a basis for different types of telehealth businesses, the 3 components of physician participation, medical risk management, and country-specific commitments must be considered to support the sustainability of teledermoscopy services [ 40 ]. Grustam et al have stated that although attention has been paid to the components of the Osterwalder model, synergy among manufacturers, health care providers, payers, and legislators is necessary to implement telescreening technology for patients with heart diseases [ 43 ].
Business-to-Business (B2B) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C) models were used in 2 studies. The aim of 1 study was to explore the systemic and economic differences in care coordination via B2B and B2C models for telemonitoring patients with chronic diseases [ 41 ], and in another study, the aim was to assess the B2C model for telemonitoring patients with chronic heart failure by analyzing its value for organizations or ventures that provided telemonitoring services [ 42 ]. In these studies, the B2C model was used with its 6 components of structure, financing, public policies, technology alignment, consumers (customers), and accountability. This model created value for customers, shareholders, service providers, and the community [ 41 , 42 ].
Furthermore, 3 studies used other existing business models [ 44 - 46 ]. Dijkstra et al used the freeband business blueprint method (FBBM) including service domain, technological domain, organizational domain, and financial domain as the components. The results indicated that costs can be divided between several telemonitoring services using a flexible infrastructure [ 44 ].
In a study conducted by Leunissen, the STOF (service, technological, organizational, and financial) model was used. The results showed that the added value in the telerehabilitation business model might be changed due to the impact of cash flows [ 45 ]. In another study, Simonse et al used the Johnson framework, which included customer value proposition, profit formula, key resources, and key processes. They noted that designing a business model is not separate from the organizational context [ 46 ]. The key aspects of the existing business models or frameworks used in the telehealth industry are illustrated in Figure 3 .
Key aspects of the existing business models or frameworks used in the telehealth industry.
The results showed that different types of business models and frameworks have been used in the telehealth industry and they have various components. However, value proposition, meeting the stakeholders’ and customers’ requirements, and financial issues were the most common components in these models and frameworks. These components might be described using different terms along with many other components, which were found important in relation to a specific type of technology and its context of use. Although new business models and frameworks focus on specific aspects of telehealth services, namely, service delivery, innovation, technology, and interface design along with other business components, the existing business models, such as Osterwalder’s business model canvas, have been used by some researchers to gain more comprehensive insight into the telehealth industry. It seems that using these business models and frameworks depends on the context of using the technology and many other components can be added to make them more appropriate for different purposes.
The aim of this study was to review different types of business models and their components used in the telehealth industry. The search process yielded 4998 articles, from which 23 studies were included in the study. These studies were divided into 2 main categories. The first category included new business models or frameworks, and the second category included the existing business models and frameworks used in telehealth industry. These models and frameworks consisted of different components in various areas of telehealth.
As mentioned earlier, business models can help implement telehealth technology with the participation of all stakeholders and in a value-based manner [ 4 ]. Business models serve as an analytical framework for identifying and overcoming barriers to the implementation and extensive use of telehealth technologies and help apply beneficial emerging technologies. These models also help identify the value proposition of telehealth services and its challenges, as well as the appropriate revenue model, organizational structure, and stakeholder engagement model [ 1 ]. However, business models must be adapted to the social, geographical, and economic contexts of the technology. Understanding each component of a business model is essential to evaluate the success of telehealth services [ 13 , 47 ]. Moreover, providing a business plan based on the well-known business models or frameworks, especially in the early stages of product development, will reduce potential risks and significantly save the costs related to the establishment of services and technologies [ 14 , 29 , 31 ].
A business model should be able to create and transfer value to the customers in a profitable and sustainable manner [ 23 , 30 ]. Therefore, some studies have emphasized the differences among the business models used for various types of telehealth technologies in each country [ 13 , 48 ]. For example, the results of the study conducted by Fredriksson et al showed that it is more appropriate to use different business frameworks for specific purposes. These frameworks should be in line with the context and purpose of using the technology [ 20 ]. However, the application of business models in the field of telehealth does not guarantee the success of new technologies, and before taking any action, legal issues and challenges related to licensing, compensation methods, liability, data sharing, and data protection must be resolved [ 28 ].
According to research findings, the main components in most telehealth business models were financial issues and cost structures that could be influenced by service processes, resources, and partners [ 33 ]. Cost structure plays an important role in customer acceptance, and different financial strategies need to be considered for various circumstances, revenue makings, and geographical areas [ 33 ]. Thus, a successful business model must be able to provide the highest value and increase the customers’ willingness to pay [ 1 , 36 ].
The results showed that it is possible to design different types of business models with various components to be used in telehealth industry. However, the components should be able to support the value of the technology in line with other components, such as the cost structure and revenue model. The components of a business model must be able to support each other, especially in unstable conditions of the health system. In addition, the components of a business model must be constantly monitored and updated [ 34 ].
A business model should ultimately lead to the acceptance of the technology by the general public. It should help in providing equitable distribution of services, effective diagnosis of diseases, and high quality of services, as well as in reducing pressure on health systems [ 35 ].
The results also revealed that some studies used existing business models or frameworks in telehealth services. Among these models, the Osterwalder business model was used more frequently than other models [ 37 - 46 ]. This model was helpful to meet the requirements of the health system and provided added value by increasing patient satisfaction and reducing the cost of care [ 37 , 43 ]. It also provided a better understanding of the business characteristics and covered various economic aspects of technology implementation [ 40 ].
A number of other studies used B2C and B2B models. The use of the B2C model allowed all stakeholders to enjoy the benefits of innovation, reduced the burden of service delivery, and improved efficiency [ 42 ]. However, when insurance companies supported the B2B model, it was more sustainable than the B2C model. Other studies used the FBBM, Johnson framework, and STOF model. The use of these models was influenced by cash flow to generate revenue and predict outcomes [ 44 - 46 ]. Similarly, Antoniotti et al showed that government and private payers are very influential in making telehealth payments and revenue policies should be considered in business models [ 49 ].
Although business sustainability is one of the major challenges lying ahead for the expanding telehealth industry, few studies have concentrated on this aspect [ 32 , 34 , 35 ]. The key aspects of the long-term sustainability of telehealth business include developing a skilled workforce, empowering consumers, reforming funding, improving digital ecosystems, and integrating telehealth into routine care. These requirements should be considered in implementation planning to ensure that effective integration of telehealth within complex health systems is in place and staff are willing to use telehealth technologies [ 50 , 51 ]. In another study, Cui et al highlighted that the sustainability of telemedicine must be improved by appropriate legislation, uniform standards, and powerful management [ 52 ].
The existing business models, especially the Osterwalder business model, are general tools and roadmaps that can provide a good understanding of business model components. However, one of its major drawbacks is the lack of sufficient emphasis on the importance of the digital economy and the functionalities of core enabling technologies. In fact, this business model cannot manage multiservice platforms and the use of other business models seems necessary to support it. Moreover, it is more product-oriented and the nature of key partner networks is less discussed in this business model [ 38 ]. In situations where the stakeholders, their roles, and the impact of their roles are different, the existing business models do not have the necessary flexibility for adaptation. Moreover, the customers (organization purchasing technology) and users (technology user) are different sometimes and considering the requirements of both groups may influence the design of the business model [ 53 ].
Overall, applying business models in the commercialization of telehealth services will be useful to gain a better understanding of the required components, stakeholders’ interactions, market challenges, and possible future changes. In fact, understanding the innovation, market size, competitive strategy, and investment in the telehealth industry is not sufficient and the impact of such an investment on the whole society should be investigated [ 38 , 42 ]. Although several business models have been proposed for use in the telehealth industry, using a combination of models and their components can help commercialize the technology more successfully. Telehealth business models can also be used in combination with traditional patient care models to double their value proposition [ 40 , 43 ].
In this study, different types of business models and their components used in the telehealth industry were reviewed and the main components necessary for a successful telehealth business were identified. However, this study has some limitations. In most of the selected studies, qualitative approaches were used. Therefore, conducting meta-analysis was not possible. Moreover, although the main databases were searched, there might be other databases that were not searched and non-English papers that were excluded from the study. These limitations can be addressed in future studies by searching more databases and changing the exclusion criteria.
The results showed that new business models used in the telehealth industry focused on legal, organizational, insurance, and customer-related issues. Added value, financial variables, financial sustainability in the market, competition, service platform, annual membership and subscription, national incentives, cost structure, and revenue streams were the other important components of these models. The studies that used existing business models mostly focused on aspects such as design, structure, governance, organizational issues, country-specific obligations, public policy, financing, profit formula, physician participation, risk management, and key processes.
In general, the diversity of business models and their components in the telehealth industry indicates that different models can be used for different telehealth technologies in various health systems and cultures. However, it is necessary to evaluate the effectiveness of these models in practice. Moreover, comparing the usefulness of these models in different domains of telehealth services will help identify the strengths and weaknesses of these models for future optimization.
This work was funded and supported by Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran (grant IUMS/SHMIS_98-1-37-14528).
B2B | Business-to-Business |
B2C | Business-to-Consumer |
CASP | Critical Appraisal Skills Programme |
mhealth | mobile health |
FBBM | freeband business blueprint method |
STOF | service, technology, organization, finance |
VISOR | value proposition, interface, service platform, organizing model, and revenue |
Multimedia appendix 2.
Conflicts of Interest: None declared.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Writing a telemedicine business plan is a crucial step toward the success of your business. Here are the key steps to consider when writing a business plan: 1. Executive Summary. An executive summary is the first section planned to offer an overview of the entire business plan. However, it is written after the entire business plan is ready and ...
This will help you create a revenue goal to make your business profitable or sustainable. It includes the primary budget you need to start a telemedicine business. Include your short-term and long-term requirements and indicate how much investment capital you need to raise or indicate, if you might need a loan.
Define targets such as the number of consultations, revenue growth, or user satisfaction levels to keep your business on track. By following these 9 essential steps, you can create a well-rounded business plan for your telehealth venture. Keep in mind that the telehealth industry is constantly evolving, so stay agile and adaptable to capitalize ...
A business plan template for telemedicine can provide several benefits for healthcare startups or established medical practices looking to launch or expand their telemedicine services. Some of these benefits include: Streamlining the planning process by providing a structured framework to follow;
Advertising your telehealth program for chronic conditions is the best way to get information out to your community and build your practice. Getting the word out could include: Printed signage near your office. Brochures and handouts in multiple languages for your waiting room and local community groups. An email or phone call to your current ...
Learn the five essential steps to implement telehealth services in your healthcare organization, from creating operational guidelines to communicating to patients. Find out how telehealth can improve efficiency, effectiveness and profitability in different specialties and settings.
For example, you may offer specialized services for individuals with chronic conditions, such as diabetes or hypertension. ... In the process of developing your telemedicine business plan, it is vital to evaluate various business models to determine the best one for your business. Telemedicine business models can differ significantly in terms ...
The telemedicine market is growing rapidly and is still projected to continue growing. According to a report by Grand View Research, the global telehealth market size was valued at USD 83.5 billion in 2022 and is projected to expand at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 24.0% from 2023 to 2030.
But with the growing demand for virtual medical services, your telemedicine healthcare services business has the potential to make a real impact. Conduct Market Research. Market research is a crucial step in developing a successful business plan for telemedicine healthcare services.
By crafting a comprehensive telemedicine business plan, entrepreneurs can navigate the complexities of the industry, secure funding, and position their ventures for long-term success. Telemedicine ...
Increase Efficiency, Increase Revenues. With efficient telemedicine software, providers are able to see more patients in the same amount of time, compared to in-person consultations. Telemedicine visits are typically 20% shorter than face-to-face visits. This increased efficiency translates into more revenues.
The Business Plan Template Summary is a working document created and supported by the ATA Business and Finance SIG work group. This document highlights the key steps of the SIG's Business Plan template full version. The business plan formalizes the business and operational goals of the organization with detailed financial information.
Embrace the future of healthcare with our Telemedicine Business Plan Template. This section offers a glimpse into the key components that make our template an indispensable resource for telemedicine entrepreneurs. In the ever-evolving healthcare landscape, the term "medical services" has taken on a transformative meaning.
The services plan refers to the "care services" to be offered using telehealth. methods. The "care services" can be primary care, specialty care, mental health, remote. monitoring or some other service. The service to be delivered defines many of the other. components of the business plan.
Here, you'll find a concise overview of 15 steps to implement a successful telemedicine program at your facility. Summary Introduction & Background Need & Demand Assessment Internal & External Assessment Service Plan Assessment Marketing Technical Plan Regulatory Environment Management Plan Financial Plan Presentation to Stakeholders Training & Testing Operations Plan Evaluation & Feedback ...
A Telehealth business plan template is a pre-designed document that provides a framework for creating a comprehensive business plan specifically tailored to a Telehealth startup. It includes sections such as executive summary, market analysis, marketing and sales plan, financial plan, and more, which serve as a roadmap for the development and ...
The title of this. dissertation is TellADoc: Business Plan for a Telemedicine Application and its purpose is. to offer a realistic plan of actions this company should follow in order to grow. Specifically. this paper is separated in two parts, the first part is the business plan part where you can.
Why Healthcare Organizationsneed a Telehealth Strategy. A bridge is typically a metaphor for creating a shortcut, crossing a chasm, or to overcome an obstacle like a river. A Telehealth Strategy serves the same purpose: to navigate you confidently across and through the uncertain future to get "to the other side".
Sample Business Plan Template a Document to Assist in the Business and Strategic Planning of Telehealth Programs - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Business Plan Template
Upmetrics' step-by-step instructions, prompts, and the library of 400+ sample business plans will guide you through each section of your plan as a business mentor. 1. Executive Summary. An executive summary is the first section of the business plan intended to provide an overview of the whole business plan.
Telemedicine Business Plan Example - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Crafting a telemedicine business plan involves strategic elements such as market analysis, service design, technology integration, and financial planning. The goal is to create an efficient virtual healthcare platform that ensures patient accessibility while prioritizing long-term ...
The business plan template is designed to be user-friendly and accessible, allowing you to get started quickly. With pre-written, researched content tailored to your specific business idea, you can easily understand the structure and flow of a professional business plan. The template is fully editable, so you can customize and adapt the content ...
A successful telemedicine business model must be safe, appropriate for the patient's needs, patient-centered, user-friendly, compliant, mission driven/strategically aligned, and have demonstrable value for the patient. ... providing a business plan based on the well-known business models or frameworks, ... For example, the results of the ...
Ensure that trained staff, available through in-person or telehealth services, promptly address urgent SUD and mental health concerns, creating a welcoming environment for immediate entry into the program. Services must include Peer Recovery Support, case management, therapist/social worker, and an on-call or in-house prescriber that has the